During a meeting of the Jogorku Kenesh committee on constitutional legislation, state structure, judicial and legal issues, and regulations, Almazbek Moldobaev, the permanent representative of the President and the Cabinet of Ministers to the Constitutional Court, reported that about ten decisions issued by the court since 2014 remain unexecuted.

Key examples of unfulfilled rulings

Moldobaev highlighted specific legal gaps and regulatory issues that persist despite court mandates. One notable case involves election laws, while another concerns tax-related travel restrictions.

  1. November 27, 2015

    The Constitutional Court ruled that restrictions preventing citizens from independently financing and campaigning for 'against all' candidates were unconstitutional, ordering Parliament to fix the legal gap.

  2. June 29, 2022

    A decision regarding parts 1 and 2 of Article 87 of the Tax Code, concerning travel restrictions for citizens with tax debts, has only been partially implemented.

Regarding the tax code ruling, the Cabinet of Ministers was tasked with clearly regulating the procedural order for hearing such cases in court. While most Constitutional Court decisions are carried out on time, several bills submitted by the Chairman of the Cabinet of Ministers have been rejected by the Jogorku Kenesh for further work.

Context

The Jogorku Kenesh deputies emphasized that Constitutional Court decisions are final, cannot be appealed, and must be executed, stressing the need for stronger cooperation in this area.